by Kirk Harris
Blade cross sectional shapes:
There are several main physical principles that can be used to make a functional cross-sectional shape.
- The gas enters the stationary fan vertically from below, and should leave the fan at as flat an angle as possible.
- Deflection: The side of the blade that faces the oncoming gas deflects the gas to change its direction.
- A space between the blades can allow gas to pass upward without deflecting it, reducing the stationary fans efficiency.
- The Coanda effect can be used on the side of the blade facing away from the oncoming gas to deflect the gas. The Coanda effect states that a stream of gas moving parallel and close to a surface will experience a force holding it close to the surface. This force results from Bernoulli’s principle. The moving gas is at a lower pressure then the atmospheric gas next to it, and so is pushed toward the surface. The surface blocks atmospheric pressure from pushing back.
Three shapes of blade cross-section to consider:
The gas on the bottom side of the blade is moderately deflected and leaves the blade at a bad angle, reducing swirl. The gas on the top side of the blade cannot form a Coanda type connection to the blade because it is not flowing parallel to the surface.
The gas on the bottom side of the blade is moderately deflected, leaving the blade at a bad angle. The sharp bend in the blade slows and disrupts the gas flow. The gas on the top side begins by moving parallel to the blade surface, and so can attach to the bottom half, but cannot stay connected because of the sharp bend. Sharp bends destroy the Coanda type connection.
The gas on the bottom side of the blade is fully and smoothly deflected to the horizontal direction. The gas on the top side of the blade begins by moving parallel to the surface, and so can form a Coanda attachment to the blade. Because of the Coanda effect, the gas can follow the smooth curve of the blade to a flat exit path. Note that the leading edge of the blade is at a right angle to the trailing edge.
Draft (buoyancy) vs. the Coanda effect
The gas moving horizontally on top of the blade is subject to two competing forces, the draft and the Coanda effect. The draft tries to direct the gas upward while the Coanda effect tries to keep the gas attached to the blade going horizontally. If the gas speed is slow and/or the connection of the gas to the blade is weak, the draft wins and the gas breaks away from the blade. The gas may be split between the two, some gas going each direction.
The gas deflected by the previous blade can join the Coanda effected gas on the current blade, countering the draft induced upward motion and improving the swirl.
The simplest stationary fan for creating swirl is made from a single round disk of sheet metal.
There may be 4 or more blades, but I will describe a 6 bladed fan, which works best for me. Draw a small circle in the center which will hold the blades together. Draw 6 radial lines from the center, outside the small circle evenly spaced at 60o each. Cut the radial lines to the small circle. If the fan is to be mounted on a shaft, drill a center hole of the appropriate size.
Bend the 6 blades as shown with red lines around the point of intersection of the radial lines with the small circle. Make the curve smooth and round so the gas can stay connected using the Coanda effect. The lower edge of the blade should point straight down, the upper edge horizontal.
The stationary fan will cause flow resistance for the gasses. This will slightly reduce the highest power level of the stove. Lower power levels are more sensitive to flow resistance and the flame may go out. A small slit, as shown in red, can reduce the flow resistance and allow higher and lower power flames. The blade must be bent as shown, from the end of the slit.
There will be an open space between the blades which will allow gasses to pass upward without being effectively deflected, reducing swirl. This type of fan can work quite well, but can be improved.
An improved version which eliminates the gap can be made from two circles. Mark three evenly spaced blades at 70o on both circles. Cut out the 50o space between. Make a short cut on the red lines. This will make room to place one circle on top of the other to form one fan with 70o blades. Spot weld the two circles together in the small center circle.
Bend the blades as before around the red lines, but with the center at what would be the 60o blade point.
The finished fan will not have the gaps and will be more efficient, especially for slow moving flame gas.
Flame gasses may escape deflection around the ends of the blade. This can cause incomplete combustion and increased particulates. This problem may be fixed by extending the blade beyond the flame, placing something to block the gasses from escaping, or by raising the center of the fan and bending the blades slightly downward as shown along the dotted lines (thus directing the flame inward).
Hi, can the swirl fan blade be adapted in a rocket stove with a chimney draft?
Would be helpful if a photo fo the fan blade be shown.
Very good information, Thanks Aprovecho.
Kirk, thanks much for this. It might help if you were to add a 3 dimensional drawing of the finished blade too!
Very well done.
Thank you for your insightful post.
I am currently busy with a wood stove. I intend to make the fans out of geopolymer ceramic, which is a challenge on its own.
Maybe your stoves could benefit as the ceramic fans will probably last forever.
I was supposed to meet you at Aprovecho, but Covid had other plans.
Please contact me if you are at all interested in collaborating with the fans.